← Back to Articles

If I Were the Devil, and What the Saints Did Instead

Paul Harvey used this form on the radio and in his column from the mid-1960s on. He imagined the devil not as a figure with horns, but as a whisper: do as you please. The form is useful if it stays a confession, and useless if it becomes a list of people to hate.

The Church already has the other half of the form. It is not a slogan. It is written in lives. The saints did not win an argument with the age. They refused the whisper, and they stayed in the Church.

If I were the devil, I would take the old name of sin and replace it with a softer one. I would call it a lifestyle, so that no one would think it could separate a person from God. Saint Mary of Egypt is the answer the calendar still reads. She left home at twelve, lived seventeen years in Alexandria by desire, and then, at the door of the church in Jerusalem, could not go in. She asked the Mother of God for a new life, crossed the Jordan, and spent nearly fifty years in the desert. The first seventeen of those years were a fight with the old memories. She did not rename them. She endured them. Elder Zosimas found her near the end, brought her Holy Communion, and later found her body, with words written in the sand that the humble Mary had died that day. The Church still reads her life with the Great Canon of Saint Andrew of Crete.

If I were the devil, I would make right and wrong follow the room. What one circle praises, another damns, and both call it love. The Sermon on the Mount does not move with the room. A person can read it before speaking. The saints did not invent a private moral code. They received the Gospel and tried to keep it when it cost them.

If I were the devil, I would turn a small difference into a war, and I would do it where no one has to see the other face. The cure in the Church is not a better post. It is the person in front of you. Saint Dionysios of Zakynthos, who died in 1624, is remembered for a hard hour of that cure. A man came to his cell with blood on his hands. He had killed the saint’s brother, Constantine. Dionysios hid him, would not hand him to the pursuers, instructed him, and brought him to repentance. Later accounts say the man became a monk in that monastery. The Church did not canonize him for a lie. It canonized a bishop who would not keep his own wound as a weapon. His body was found incorrupt, and the Patriarchate of Constantinople entered him in the calendar in 1703.

If I were the devil, I would call forgiveness weakness and revenge honesty. Forgiveness is not the claim that nothing happened. Dionysios wept. He still opened the door.

If I were the devil, I would use a real scandal to make the whole Church look false. A fallen priest is not a reason to leave Christ. He is a reason to tell the truth, to pray for the wounded, and to stay with the altar. The saints stayed. Saint Luke of Crimea, Valentin Voyno-Yasenetsky, was a surgeon and a bishop. He wrote on purulent surgery, served the sick, and was sent into exile for more than eleven years. He did not answer the state’s contempt by leaving the Church. He served the Liturgy and kept both the knife and the Gospel. He died in 1961, blind, and was canonized in 1996.

If I were the devil, I would keep a person scrolling until prayer felt like an interruption. Mary of Egypt had no screen. She had memory, hunger, and years. The same fight fits a smaller hour. A fast, a psalm, or ten minutes with the phone in another room is a beginning, not a performance.

If I were the devil, I would leave a person alone and call it freedom. The saints were not saved as an audience. Zosimas brought Communion to Mary. Dionysios received a murderer into repentance. Luke served a diocese. The parish is the ordinary form of that life. Go where the people are. Learn their names.

If I were the devil, I would define love as the self, kept comfortable. Christ did not love that way. He washed feet. He went to the Cross. The lives above are small copies of that, not a program.

If I were the devil, I would set science and faith against each other, as if one had to kill the other. Luke of Crimea is enough to refuse that quarrel. He was a professor of surgery and an archbishop. The world is real. God is not a gap in it.

If I were the devil, I would make faith feel late. The hours are the same hours they always were. Morning prayer still fits in them. So does the Liturgy.

The devil’s work, in this form, is to divide a person from God and from the neighbor, and then to offer a side to stand on. The saints did not answer him with a side. They answered with repentance, forgiveness, work, and the Church. That is the cure the calendar keeps.

A website cannot pastor you. Find a parish.

Sources: Paul Harvey’s piece, Snopes, https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/if-i-were-the-devil/ — Saint Dionysios, https://www.johnsanidopoulos.com/2019/12/the-saint-who-lied-to-save-his-brothers.html — Saint Luke, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luke_Voyno-Yasenetsky — Saint Mary of Egypt, the life read with the Great Canon.


Author:

Editorial Standard:
Website Standards version not yet assigned.
Last updated:
October 2, 2026


This work is an offering. Your prayers matter.

A website cannot pastor you. Find a parish.

May God bless you.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *