← Back to Articles

Makeup, the Body, and What the Church Received

Paint on the face is older than the argument about it. The record is enough. The rumor is not.

Egypt: men, women, and children

In ancient Egypt, green eye-paint and later black kohl were used by men, women, and children, across social ranks. A review of the archaeological and literary record gives the uses as cosmetic, medicinal, and religious. Scholars agree on that range even where dates and recipes differ. People also believed kohl cut the sun’s glare and kept dust and flies from the eyes. A richer person wore a finer powder. A poorer person mixed in soot. The difference was status, not a rule that only women might paint the eyes.

Rome: who complained, and why

Rome left a different record, and almost all of it was written by men.

Juvenal was a Roman satirist of the early second century. He wrote that a woman buys scents and lotions with adultery in mind. Seneca was a Roman statesman and Stoic teacher of the first century. He told women who wanted to be thought virtuous to avoid cosmetics. Ovid, the poet of the age of Augustus, is the exception among surviving authors: he wrote a short poem on medicines for the face and approved their use.

A man who carried a mirror, or who whitened his face, was mocked. Roman writers expected a man to be tanned from work outdoors. A pale, painted face looked like leisure, and like a lie. Otho, who was emperor for three months in the year 69, was mocked for shaving every day and putting a bread pack on his face. Elagabalus, emperor from 218 to 222, was mocked for removing his body hair and wearing makeup. The charge was vanity and deceit. It was not a theory that paint could make a man into a woman.

The Christian teachers, and what they meant

The Church took up that charge and set it under Scripture. In the first letter of Peter, wives are told not to let their adorning be the outward arranging of hair, gold, and fine clothes, but the hidden person of the heart.

Clement of Alexandria was a Christian teacher in Egypt in the late second century. Around the year 195 he wrote a book of instruction for believers, later called The Instructor. In it he asks what remains to be said about staining the eyes, painting the face with rouge and white lead, and dyeing the hair, once Christ has already told his people not to be anxious about clothes. He calls those arts deceptions.

Tertullian was a Christian writer in Carthage, in North Africa, a few years later. Around the year 198 he wrote On the Apparel of Women. He says that women who rub the skin with ointments, stain the cheeks with rouge, and darken the eyes with antimony sin against God, because what is born is God’s work and what is plastered on is not. He also refuses the opposite excess. He is not asking for dirt and neglect. He is asking for a limit.

John Chrysostom was a priest in Antioch and later archbishop of Constantinople, at the end of the fourth century and the start of the fifth. He is remembered as a preacher. In a baptismal instruction he warns the newly baptized that painted beauty, used to draw the eyes of undisciplined men, puts the weight of that sin on the one who invited it.

None of these men says that paint creates a sex. They say that a face can be made to lie, and that vanity is a sickness of the soul. A woman who wears a little color to a feast has not changed the doctrine of creation. A man who will not be seen as a man has entered a different question.

What is not in the sources

That question is not settled by a rumor about hidden queens. Claims that past rulers were men living as women, and that royal children were therefore not of the blood, do not appear in the Egyptian, Roman, or patristic sources named here. They do not belong on this page.

What the Church still teaches

The Orthodox Church teaches that God made human beings male and female, and that this difference belongs to the creation God called very good. The Orthodox Church in America restated that in a synodal statement in 2022: God made human beings in two sexes, male and female, and this is his plan from the beginning. The same statement asks pastoral care, not contempt, for people who struggle with passion and temptation.

In December 2017 a public letter, “Created Male and Female,” was signed by religious leaders in the United States, including Orthodox bishops. It says a person is male or female, that the difference is a gift, and that discomfort with one’s sex is a complicated reality that needs sensitivity and truth.

So the page can say this much, and no more than the sources bear. Kohl was worn by Egyptian men and women. Roman men who painted the face were mocked by other Romans. Christian teachers in Alexandria, Carthage, and Constantinople condemned cosmetics as deceit and vanity, and asked for measure, not for a war on every jar. The Church receives the body as given. Paint can hide a blemish. It cannot rewrite what a person is.

The person, and the parish

A person who cannot bear the body they were given is still a person the parish is for. The sources that confess male and female also forbid the Church to sneer. A male body in a women’s competition is a question about the body, not about powder. It can be named without being used as a weapon.

The cure on this page is the one the texts already give. Do not live for the mirror. Do not call God’s work a costume. Bring the distress, and the vanity, to confession and to the Liturgy.

A website cannot pastor you. Find a parish.

Sources

•  A. D. Hardy and others, “Egyptian eye cosmetics (Kohls): Past and present,” in Physical Techniques in the Study of Art, Archaeology and Cultural Heritage, vol. 1 (2006). Chapter PDF: https://egittolizzando.altervista.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/Egyptian-Eye-Cosmetics-Kohls-Past-and-Present.pdf

•  Publisher page: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1871173106800060

•  “Ophthalmology of the Pharaohs: Antimicrobial Kohl Eyeliner in Ancient Egypt,” Discover Magazine, 21 April 2012. https://www.discovermagazine.com/ophthalmology-of-the-pharaohs-antimicrobial-kohl-eyeliner-in-ancient-egypt-5498

•  “Cosmetics in Ancient Rome,” Wikipedia, section “Men’s attitudes toward cosmetics” (Juvenal, Seneca, Ovid, Otho, Elagabalus). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmetics_in_Ancient_Rome

•  Mark Cartwright, “Cosmetics in the Ancient World,” World History Encyclopedia, 6 September 2019. https://www.worldhistory.org/article/1441/cosmetics-in-the-ancient-world/

•  “Cosmetics / Makeup,” Ante-Nicene Christianity, quotations from Clement of Alexandria, Tertullian, and John Chrysostom. https://ante-nicenechristianity.com/dictionary/cosmetics/

•  “Man,” The Orthodox Faith, Doctrine and Scripture, Orthodox Church in America. https://www.oca.org/orthodoxy/the-orthodox-faith/doctrine-scripture/the-symbol-of-faith/man

•  Holy Synod of the Orthodox Church in America, statement on same-sex relationships and sexual identity, 2022. https://www.oca.org/holy-synod/statements/holy-synod/holy-synod-issues-statement-on-same-sex-relationships-and-sexual-identity

•  “Created Male and Female: An Open Letter from Religious Leaders,” 15 December 2017, noting Orthodox signatures, as reprinted by Orthodoxy in Dialogue. https://orthodoxyindialogue.com/2018/12/20/created-male-and-female-two-prominent-orthodox-signatures-on-anti-transgender-letter/


Author:

Editorial Standard:
Website Standards version not yet assigned.
Last updated:
October 3, 2026


This work is an offering. Your prayers matter.

A website cannot pastor you. Find a parish.

May God bless you.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *