On Sunday, 20 July 1986, a local television station in Erie, Pennsylvania, recorded the Divine Liturgy at the Church of the Nativity of Christ. The service was sung in English, according to the Old Rite. Two days later, on the afternoon of 22 July, the original church burned. The recording is the last liturgy ever served in that building.
The church stood on the bayfront. It had been finished in 1919 by priestless Old Believers, Pomortsy, who had come to Erie for work on the docks. For many years a nastavnik led the prayers. In January 1983 about four-fifths of the parish voted to enter the Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia. On 24 July 1983 Archbishop Laurus ordained Father Pimen Simon. The church was consecrated. That August, on the feast of the Dormition, more than five hundred people were chrismated and received Holy Communion. The old books stayed. The priesthood returned.
By the summer of 1986 the parish was preparing to host a week-long Orthodox conference. On 22 July a worker saw smoke coming from the ceiling vent over the choir. The attic was old timber. It caught quickly. Flames broke through the roof. Parts of the ceiling fell. A large chandelier bought in Greece crashed to the floor. The walls bowed outward.
The parish account says what was found after the fire. The royal doors, the deacons’ doors, the iconostasis, the icons, the books, the altar, the vestments, and the sanctuary were still there, and not burned. By evening the people had moved from shock to thanksgiving. They kept the conference. They prayed for a time in the community center. They chose to rebuild on the same ground. The new church was dedicated on the feast of the Dormition, 28 August 1987. It still stands by the water. The Old Rite is still served there in English.
For the Old Rite in America, the recording matters because it keeps a sound that could have been lost. This was the first parish in the country to receive the priesthood while keeping the pre-reform books and chant. The film shows that life already under way: English words set to the old melodies, a full liturgy, a parish no longer priestless. The fire came only three years after the Mysteries returned. It did not end them. The people carried out what could be saved, and they built again.
The wound of the seventeenth century is real. This film is not an argument about it. It is a parish at prayer, and then a parish that lost its building and did not lose the service.
The film ends. The parish did not. The people carried out what could be saved, and they built again on the same ground. The Old Rite is still served there, by the water, in English. If this recording has stirred you to pray, go where the service is still sung. Find a parish and stand with the Church.
Watch the recorded liturgy service here:


Leave a Reply